Man I have no idea. When in doubt start over. Flash your fast boot files and then flash the theme again and see if that fixed itAwesome, always love when I'm the only person with strange issues! Any suggestions for how I can fix this??
Edit: I don't think it was the theme. I used the return to stock zip in the OP, then manually changed my battery icon in Rom Toolbox. Came out with the same result unfortunately - the system report doesn't match what the icon shows
Sent from my ROOTED SAFE STRAPPED RAZRX RAZR ROCKIN XOOMZOOM